DLER：正确实施长度惩罚——通过强化学习激励每个Token蕴含更多智能

DLER: Doing Length pEnalty Right - Incentivizing More Intelligence per Token via Reinforcement Learning

October 16, 2025

作者: Shih-Yang Liu, Xin Dong, Ximing Lu, Shizhe Diao, Mingjie Liu, Min-Hung Chen, Hongxu Yin, Yu-Chiang Frank Wang, Kwang-Ting Cheng, Yejin Choi, Jan Kautz, Pavlo Molchanov

cs.AI

摘要

诸如OpenAI-o1、DeepSeek-R1和Qwen等推理语言模型通过扩展思维链实现了强劲的性能，但往往生成不必要的冗长输出。最大化每单位token的智能——即准确性与响应长度之比——仍是一个待解决的难题。我们重新审视了强化学习（RL），采用最简单的长度惩罚——截断——并证明准确性的下降并非源于缺乏复杂的惩罚机制，而是由于RL优化不足所致。我们识别出三大关键挑战：(i)优势估计中的显著偏差，(ii)熵的崩溃，以及(iii)稀疏的奖励信号。针对这些问题，我们提出了“正确实施长度惩罚”（DLER），这一训练方案结合了批次奖励归一化、更高截断值、动态采样及简单的截断长度惩罚。DLER在准确性与效率的权衡上达到了业界领先水平，将输出长度削减超过70%，同时超越了所有先前基线的准确性。它还提升了测试时的扩展性：与DeepSeek-R1-7B相比，DLER-7B能并行生成多个简洁响应，准确率提高28%，且延迟更低。我们进一步引入了难度感知的DLER，它根据问题难度自适应地收紧截断，以实现额外的效率提升。此外，我们提出了一种更新选择性合并方法，在保持基线准确性的同时，保留了DLER模型的简洁推理能力，这对于RL训练数据稀缺的场景尤为有用。

English

Reasoning language models such as OpenAI-o1, DeepSeek-R1, and Qwen achieve strong performance via extended chains of thought but often generate unnecessarily long outputs. Maximizing intelligence per token--accuracy relative to response length--remains an open problem. We revisit reinforcement learning (RL) with the simplest length penalty--truncation--and show that accuracy degradation arises not from the lack of sophisticated penalties but from inadequate RL optimization. We identify three key challenges: (i) large bias in advantage estimation, (ii) entropy collapse, and (iii) sparse reward signal. We address them with Doing Length pEnalty Right (DLER), a training recipe combining batch-wise reward normalization, higher clipping, dynamic sampling, and a simple truncation length penalty. DLER achieves state-of-the-art accuracy--efficiency trade-offs, cutting output length by over 70 percent while surpassing all previous baseline accuracy. It also improves test-time scaling: compared to DeepSeek-R1-7B, DLER-7B generates multiple concise responses in parallel with 28 percent higher accuracy and lower latency. We further introduce Difficulty-Aware DLER, which adaptively tightens truncation on easier questions for additional efficiency gains. We also propose an update-selective merging method that preserves baseline accuracy while retaining the concise reasoning ability of the DLER model, which is useful for scenarios where RL training data is scarce.